Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutPZC Minutes 10.21.20261 DRAFT LINCOLN COUNTY PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION MEETING MINUTES Wednesday, October 21st, 2026, 6:00 P.M. Locations: Video Conference between the following locations: Lincoln County Courthouse, Commissioner Boardroom 925 Sage Avenue 3rd Floor, Kemmerer, WY & Afton Planning & Development Office, Conference Room, 61 East 5th Avenue, Afton, WY I. CALL TO ORDER Karen Anderson called the meeting to order at 6:02 p.m. II. INTRODUCTION OF PZC MEMBERS Planning Commission Members: Karen Anderson, Chair Chad Jensen, Vice Chair Kevin Kilroy David Oates Hunter Jasperson Lincoln County Staff: Austin Dunlap, Deputy County Attorney Ken Kuluski, Planning Director David Pitlock, Planner I Sydney Jasperson, Secretary III. ADOPTION OF AGENDA Chad motioned to adopt the agenda, David seconded. Motion passed 5-0. IV. APPROVAL OF MINUTES Chad requested clarification on the minutes on page 3, where within the project the minutes state “ this project also received a letter from the State Engineer’s Office that there was not adequate staff to review the project, with request to apply for wells and water rights appropriately.” Karen verified that was spoken about in the prior meeting. Ken explained that the letter received explained that the proper permits would still need to be acquired by applicants in the future. Kevin motioned to approve the minutes as is, Hunter seconded. Motion passed 4-0 with Chad abstaining. V. DEVELOPMENT REPORT Karen addressed the public to poll the audience on which project they intended to speak on. After polling the audience there was discussion about moving the arrangement of the agenda to benefit the 2 speakers for the LUR Chapter 7 changes. After discussion with Austin and Ken, Karen decided that the agenda did not need to be revisited. Ken presented the Development Report of approved permits from August 24, 2026, to September 27th, 2026. There were 17 North Lincoln Permits, one South Lincoln County Residential Use Permit. 23 Small Wastewater Permits. Three Zoning and Development Permits – All Cellular Towers, and one Temporary Use Permit. Kevin had questions about the lot size of the first permit, siting the multiple buildings and why there isn’t lot size listed on the worksheet. VI. ACTION ITEMS A. 116 CUP 26 Bird Family Cemetery a. A Conditional Use Permit to create a 40’ X 40’ Family Cemetery in Bedford, Wyoming, on 5+/- acres in the Rural Zone. The remaining 4.9+/- acres will continue its use. b. Located approximately 1.8 miles southeast of the Town of Thayne, Wyoming, in T34N, R118W Section 31. David Pitlock presented the Bird Family Cemetery, a 40’ X 40’ or 1,600 sqft portion of the lot that will be used for the burial of human or animal remains. Hunter stated that due to a relation to the family he must recuse himself. Karen had a question about the condition of approval, the number of lots and that the true number of burial plots should be on the recorded plat. Chad asked about the remaining acres and if there was potential for a future house or subdivision. David answered that the intended use is to be vacant land. Mikayla Tingey from Surveyor Scherbels added that there would be 24 burial plots and addressed Chads question about a future house stating that the remaining portion of the parcel does not meet the LUR minimum of 5 acres for subdividing, but yes there could be a house built should the property owners apply for that permit. Karen asked about amending the condition of approval. Kevin motioned to approve File 116 CUP 26 Bird Family Cemetery with alterations to the condition of approval #3 to state “any alterations”. Karen seconded. Motion passed 4-0 with Hunter recusing himself. B. 119 CUP 26 Bench 19 Guest Cabins c. A Conditional Use Permit to allow one (1) main residence, one (1) guest home, and four (4) guest cabins on 19.05+/- acres in the Rural Zone. d. Located approximately 3 miles northeast of the Town of Thayne, Wyoming, in T34N, R118W Section 17. David Pitlock presented the Bench 19 Guest Cabins for one main residence, one new construction guest house, and four guest cabins. The main residence will be 2,200 square feet, the guest house will be 1,200 square feet and each guest cabin will be 400 square feet. There are no proposed employees or office spaces. The guest cabins will be used as short- term rentals with an estimated maximum of fourteen guests per day. There are no known similar uses within 300 feet currently. Karen asked about the parking plan, David responded that there was a 30-foot gravel drive. Chad had a question relating to condition #4 ‘Buffering’ wanting elaboration on what exactly the buffering would be. He also wanted to know if there really was no other use like 3 this in the County and if this was a conditional use permit. David reiterated his introduction that there was no similar use within 300 feet and that this is a Conditional Use Permit. Karen asked, ‘what would happen if the CUP was not granted?’. Ken explained the order of appeal and reapplication. Karen asked about overlays and information about the surrounding area, asking for the vicinity map. Ken responded that the parcel in question is surrounded by large parcels of undeveloped land. Mikayla Tingey spoke and addressed some of the questions, stating that this parcel sits on the Bedford Bench, that parking is outlined on the site plan that meets the mandatory two spots her residence requirement. Mikayla answered Chad’s question about buffering, that the Land Use Regulations outline buffering to be a 6-foot opaque fence or a vegetated berm. - Internet/ connection was broken for 5 minutes - David Oates asked about the access road and who would be responsible for that (maintenance wise). Mikayla stated that it would be the landowner who is responsible for the 20-foot-wide road. Karen asked about noticing the neighbors, Mikayla confirmed that there was proper noticing. David Oates asked about snow removal and whether or not it would end up in the neighbor’s yard. Mikayla stated that there is an agricultural buffer, so there should not be encroachment on the neighboring properties. Discussion between the Commission and Mikayla about maximum occupancy. Karen called for public comment and a gentleman named Doug Jenkins came up to speak. His question was ‘What is the right-of-way required to get down there?’ but added interest in snow storage and road maintenance. Discussion between Doug, Ken and the Commission about snow storage, road width and potential subdivision. Marlowe Scherbel joined the discussion to add information about the setbacks and potential for subdivision and the road requirements. Bob Gonet came up to speak. He conducted research on the internet on Air BnB and VRBO (Vacation Rental by Owner) and found that there was a plethora of rentals available to visitors in the Bedford/ Star Valley Ranch area. He asked a question to the Commission ‘how does this serve the public?’ Discussion ensued between the Commission, Ken and Bob about rentals and the character of the county. Scott Balko spoke on the issue as well, stating that he lives in the area, 1/8 of a mile away from the project. The discussion centered around the buffering issue and road maintenance. Discussion between the Commission and Mikayla Tingey around the maps and site layout. Karen made mention that she would like the maps projected on the big screen in the future. Karen confirmed with the other members of the Commission that they were ready to move forward and called for a vote. Chad motioned to approve with the addition of a condition of approval #8 for a snow removal plan and the 20-foot driveway. David seconded motion passed 3-2. 4 C. 206 MS 26 Bitter Creek Ranches Seventh Filing / East Bitter Creek Ranches Second Filing a. A Minor Subdivision proposal to subdivide 20.0+/- acres into two (2) residential lots with an average lot size of 10.0 acres +/- in the Rural Zone. The subdivision will have access from Bitter Creek County Road 140. b. Located approximately 1.8 miles west of the Town of Afton, Wyoming in T32N, R119W, Section 34. Ken presented Bitter Creek Ranches Seventh Filing and East Bitter Creek Ranches Second Filing, specificizing that the lots will be serviced by private wells and septics in accordance with Land Use Regulations and the State Engineers Office. There were no questions for Ken, or Scherbels Office. No one from the public wanted to speak. David Oates motioned to accept file #206 MS 26 Bitter Creek Ranches seventh filing, East Bitter Creek Ranches Second Filing. Hunter Seconded. Motion passed 5-0. D. 604 PZ 25 Land Use Regulations Amendment Land Use Definitions and Table a. A Proposed Amendment to the Lincoln County Land Use Regulations to modify Land Use Definitions, Subcategories and Table in Chapter 7.1, 7.2, and 7.3 which will address modern requests for land usage and promote a better understanding of the planning process. Proposal A. Modify language and definitions in Chapter 7.1 Land Use Definitions. Proposal B. Modify Land Use and Small Business Subcategories. Proposal C. Modify Land Use Table 7.3. b. All unincorporated areas within Lincoln County. Ken presented “alright so the main event, after the prelims here, the land use regulation adoption process, just so were all up to speed it starts with concerns voiced by the communities in the county, direction from the P&Z Board and various state agencies providing input. Then we start with public meetings and workshops to work on the projects and considerations and see which one we want to work with more, and which one we can move to a different area, or better address the situations. Then we narrow it down to a proposal. This has been a long, ongoing review of where we all wish the LUR to go. This is part of a bigger process as the county works toward reviewing it LURs. We’re reviewing the appendices as well. That’s – its all part of the investment by the Commission to update the regulation and comprehensive Plan. So this LUR covers definitions only, alright? Any other implemented actions, okay? So you’ll talk about an RV permit, okay? Ultimately its the Board of County Commissioners who have the say if we want to have an RV permit because right now we permit RVs under residential use permits and I’ll explain that in a minute. So once we find out that we’re gonna have a new permit process that permit process will be amended in chapter 2, permitting procedures and we will come back through this process and iron out what that permit will look like and how we’re gonna use it. Why we’re here now in the wintertime to get it ready for the spring, hopefully. There is a lot of new issues inside chapter 7. We have a lot of new developments, wind, solar, data centers, just to name a few. As always, as the chair brought up earlier we always want to balance the protection of private property rights with the needs of public health and safety. This recommendation is no 5 different. What this LUR does not change; I don’t mess with private RVs being used on private property that are not connected to anything, I never have required a permit for that and there’s no desire change that. We’re looking at RVs that are being used as houses, right? What we call those is connected to power, water, sewer or gas. So the problem we have, brought by the P&Z Commission and my agencies and the community is how do I protect the RV use and make sure that the floodplains, our watersheds and our wetlands that’s being taken care of, right? We have a lot of concerns about the Salt/Snake [river] tributaries and then for the southern.. you southern folks down there, Hams Fork and the Green River tributaries. Concerns about people being inside the setbacks, litter, septic, fluids all types of concerns so we’re trying to address that. And second, we don’t, we never really have really liked RV’s as a house. People throughout many conversations have said an RV’s not really a house here, its too cold so how do we define RVs so that we can have an idea how to get a permanent residence? Again, hooking up to utilities what we call substructure, how do we get those and make sure that they’re meeting our requirements and meeting our land use regulations? That’s really the goal. So for temporary use permits, we allow those for things up to 120 days. Theres some additions to the permitting 7-3, just so you guys keep aware that’s allowing use for up to 120 days. What do we have now? Where do I get the idea that RVs are a house? So a dwelling, a building or portions of it containing one or more living units. The term does not include any self-contained RV. Once again, self-contained RV does not connect to anything, and its ecosystem does not need any external input. Once you add in water or take sewer out that’s an external input. Also, it doesn’t count anything covered by a CUP or a Zoning and Development permit. Things like motels, hotels, clubs and short-term rentals such as bed and breakfast – that’s a separate permitting process. Established permitting processes will not be changed, so your Chaparo, trailer park, Star Valley Ranch RV those already established and well-developed parks wont be effected. They will follow their guidelines of the HOAs and the governing documents for those two RV parks, just to name some. There is more than that, I cant remember all of them. So at this time, we’ve had workshops, we’ve had a couple of times I came, we talked about it, we put it off and had some more input, came back. So this is the time for the P&Z board and the community to discuss and recommend amendments to the proposal. So if you wanted a copy of the proposal there’s some sitting on the table out there, like 10 of them, I don’t have enough for everybody. But anything inside the LUR can be amended or changed at this hearing. We will just like the projects we saw before they can make an amendment, they can discuss it, we can vote on it as we go forward and we’ll make those changes to the final document. That being said, we want to try and remain positive and work together to move the community forward, alright? So I would recommend, two things, to handle this. Due to the situation I’d recommend that we address the hot topics first, kind of, madam chair, as you brought up earlier, if you wanted to move it, I’m supporting [of] that in my recommendation that we talk about the key issues that the public has and address those so that once they have had their voices heard on those key issues then they will feel more inclined to be able to leave, because their voices were heard. Secondly because this is a long document it is done by page numbers I recommend that as we go through the process we do have to go through 6 it probably in sequence. There’ll be a motion and vote for each page. That will keep our notes segmented for the recording in case we missed something and also allow us not to have motions that are so complex we cant remember what was said. So basically, if you look at each little page as basically its own project. Those are just recommendations from talking to people in the community. With that being said, you introduced it, I’m ready to turn it over to you madam chair.” Karen clarified in the LUR table 1.1 notes the process and that chapter 7 amendments are on the sixth step. Karen clarified the options for the Chapter 7 amendment for the new Commission member and the next steps if the amendment was tabled or denied. Ken clarified that appealing a denial would not be beneficial for the community, Karen did clarify that the process would take the appeal to the Board of County Commissioners. Ken agreed but reiterated that he would not do that and instead would restart the process so that the Planning and Zoning Commission would have another chance to review it. Commentary from Karen about the substantial changes to the Land Use Regulations, thus changing the Law which the planning office abides by. Discussion amongst the Commission to address the concerns of the public first, Karen outlined the Roberts Rules of Order, specifically the three minute maximum and the request that if someone’s talking point is brought up that they do not bring it up again. Chad had questions about the letters and emails that were laid out on the table for the Commission to review in conjunction with the LUR changes. Ken explained the correspondence with the Planning Staff (emails & letters) and explained how the LUR change would not affect the currently platted RV Parks. More discussion between the Commission and Ken about the gravity of the situation and how impactful the changes will be and how to approach it. Karen opened the floor to the public, asking that as a group we alternate between Kemmerer speakers and Afton speakers until the public has spoken completely. She reiterated Roberts Rules of Order that there should not be back and forth discussion and everyone should keep their comments to three minutes or less. Aaron Laverty stated that he resides in the Oakley subdivision outside of Kemmerer, his major concern was related to a post put out on Facebook that was interpreted to convey that anyone who had more than one camper on their personal property would have to get a permit for any additional campers. He explained that the concern was the restrictions to his ability to house guests for increments of time and that he has a personal camper that he keeps hooked up on his property for his own use. He does not want to see an additional financial burden to be placed on his visitors as he allows them free use of his property by not charging them a fee. He directly wants to know what problem is being solved by requiring a permit? Karen reiterated that there would not be a free-flowing discussion. A gentleman from the audience insisted that the Commission discuss the camper/ RV issue before he came up to speak his piece. He then stepped up and addressed the whole Commission and audience. Clay Marbo, who lives out on Bitter Creek stated that this issue did not affect him personally, but he recognizes that it will affect a lot of Lincoln County residents. He was concerned that the way things were written in the LUR Changes that if, for instance, someone were to host a wedding and people attended campers or RV’s that the landowner or each individual camper owner would 7 have to obtain a permit for the weekend. He stated that he felt this was an invasion of privacy on private property, that the Commission does not fully understand how upset people really are. Shannon Rickert spoke next, stating that she owns 70 acres split into two parcels. One holds a residence, and one has power connectivity. She states that she’s already paid for the permit to have power out at the second location and is confused that she would need another permit to operate her own camper on her own property with power she already pays for, on top of all the taxes she already pays. Karen redirected and allowed Ken to answer this question according to how the new definition would define the camper/RV experience. Kens’ explanation was that the camper/RV would have to remain self-contained. I.E. no input or output. If the camper/RV is no longer self-contained and is used for a dwelling it requires a permit. He reiterated that any connection to substructure or utility would require a permit. Discussion between the board and Ken about what a permit would entail to secure the safety of utilities and septic. Clay Marbo spoke a second time to Ken, Karen redirected him to speak to the board. He wanted to know how the permitting process was going to solve a problem by penalizing people across the county. Jessica Lozier spoke next; she felt that this way of going about things was a blanket solution and instead should be rewritten to address things more specifically. She provided the example that on her ranch during branding weekend there may be 25 people camping on the ranch to assist with branding over the weekend. The campers plug into the barn so there are not 25 generators running on the ranch, and if they are being used for two days they aren’t residences. Another problem people might have problems with is the change in permitting for the Fossil Quarries. She was also concerned about Data Centers and was concerned about the permitting process for those. Julie Jonston spoke next, stating that this was too big a project to be dealt with in such a short span of time. She stated that she could not find public notice about the changes to the LUR and had to go out of her way to find it on her phone. She is unclear as to why it is being changed, and if it’s necessary. Kim McKee spoke next. He explained the property where he keeps his horses, and how they use it for recreation. He leaves a trailer there for a couple of weeks at a time before he needs to move it to dump the black water. He stated that no one is illegally dumping on his property. He is strongly against making people get a permit for personal property usage. He stated that he didn’t know how one would even moderate that, his property is posted ‘No Trespassing’. Matthew Barber stated that he was concerned about the cost of the permit for second RV. He explained his ownership of several lots and how he provides a reasonable place to live for his employees. He thinks that he should be allowed to do what he thinks is reasonable on his property. 8 Mary Service spoke next; she brought something to read from because she felt it was important. She stated that they own property up on commissary ranch. She stated that the government needs to pro-manage their monies instead of imposing ridiculous fees on people who are just trying to be a family. She found it odd that in Lincoln County someone could bury their deceased family members on their property but not have relatives come stay in a camper for the weekend. She also stated that her property is also posted ‘Private Property”, “No Trespassing”. Karl Titensor spoke, stating that power should not denote a residence, but septic should because it truly changes the land use. For the people that are illegally dumping in public lands or even private the fines should be upped to not penalize the greater community. Kim McKee spoke again, he talked to Stephen Allen, the problem is 4-5 trailers were visiting from Utah and improperly dumping. His solution is to send the sheriff to the land and fine the landowner or the renters. Chris Barton spoke, stating that he thinks this is growth of government and an overreach. He asked ‘How does this benefit the community? Or does this infringe on personal property rights?’. - Internet Slipped again - Laurie McKee spoke next, stating that in Kemmerer there is no public dumping area in south Lincoln County. The woman who owns the campground near Kemmerer allows people to dump their black water, and they do pay her. She stated that most places that encourage outdoor activities have public dumping spaces. Gary Deaton spoke, with appreciation for the accessory building permits. Jeremy Call spoke next, “I’m Jeremy Call, C-A-L-L. I’m [the] owner of [a] planning firm Logan Simpson. We help communities guide responsible change throughout Wyoming and around the West. We prepared Land Use quotes, comprehensive plans and economic development plans. And this is an important step. This is hard for all of us, and its kind of beyond our education level, and I don’t like doing land use codes either, because we end up in conversations like this, but it’s important because it helps us accomplish our goals. And while I – While I’m not here to speak about RVs, I think we share common goals and Land Use Codes help us accomplish those goals. They’re not the goal, they’re just a regulation that get us towards the goal. So, one area that the Planning Commission and Planning Staff can help us better accomplish our goals is to align goals with regulations. For example; Invest, invest Diamondville Kemmerer as a strong south Lincoln County Economic Development Coalition. They’ve been working actively to help transition South County from traditionally reliant coal economy to an all-of-the-above energy and enhanced manufacturing economy with technology and better paying jobs, permanent jobs. If I go to the Invest Kemmerer Diamondville Website, and I look at their targeted communities, or targeted industries page, right, and I see on there, manufacturing, coal, natural gas, etc. I would want to go to the Land Use Regulations and see that those targeted industries conveniently fit in here, and that is a streamlines process. I’m bringing here tonight, I drove up from Kemmerer so you can see me in person, because the type of manufacturing, 9 nuclear, coal, natural gas, listed as targeted industries are not found in the Land Use code, creating suspicion or hesitancy to invest. We know that there’s been tremendous efforts to invest in nuclear, but there is not a pathway for nuclear. It seems like nuclear could be on the land use table, table 7.3 and create a rule for nuclear. Identify where its allowed, it would seem like its allowable in industrial areas right? Not residential. So, with that in mind, let me just highlight, if I could, three places for some simple improvement. On page ten, under definition of heavy industrial, you might add words, page 10 heavy industrial, has the words heavy manufacturer. You have a light manufacturing section but there’ s not one for heavy manufacturing, like steel and aluminum recycling and production. Again, that’s straight out of the targeted industries, you can pull some words right off the bat. Second you go to page, 16. At the bottom, utility company buildings. We can agree that energy production is a utility. We’re serving a public good and connecting to the regional electrical grid right? And so nuclear, coal generations, natural gas generation, you might add other types of electrical generation, should be under utilities. Right now, it’s not found. It’s intuitively there, right and its been interpreted like that. It would be – give more confidence. Let me add one more phrase to the utility company buildings, which is energy storage. There’s many ways that we can store energy at nighttime when the energy is affordable and then release it during the day, and that keep energy prices low for everybody. Energy storage, there’s many different ways to do that. Chemical, like lithium ion or ion air. It could be hydrogen and chemical conversation, it could be gravity. Simply saying energy storage in that definition makes it clear where utilities are acceptable. And then lastly, in the land use table, this is the second page of the table, and this is my last point so thank you for bearing with me. The second row is called industrial heaven and I think we can all agree that industrial uses are appropriate in industrial zones. They’re not appropriate in residential, mixed or commercial etc. and you’’ see that the acronym CU there, for conditional use is different than what you see for oil and gas development in an industrial zone which is a Z&D or other utilities, or utility buildings which is a Z&D. [It would] be helpful to align those so that industrial development occurs in the industrial zones using the same process, so that different facilities in that zone don’t have to go through different permit steps. So, thank you very much for your time and [I] appreciate you working through this. Marlowe Scherbel then spoke with the Commission about the overall meeting information, the processes and the types of permits he had seen over his years working with Planning and Development. He suggested some more workshops so that the public and the Commission could rework the major issues brought up in the meeting. Ken joined the discussion about what he would like to see, permits for RV’s and then that process would be brought to the Planning and Zoning Commission at a later date. Julie Jonston spoke again stating that there was more than just the RV issue, people just don’t want to come out and talk about it. She stated that to pass the LUR change tonight would be ‘insane’ and table it so that private citizens can have their own attorneys look at it. Karen then closed the public comment portion and Karen stated “I will hop out of the gate that I did start through the packet. I’ll just say a couple things, just on the first three pages. 10 7.1 Definitions. Unless the context otherwise specifies the followings words, terms strike, and phrases and their derivatives shall be interpreted, no in the same fashion but now by the Planning Director. I feel that kind of gives the Planning Director unilateral authority to interpret the language from here on out on any discrepancy between the directors. You’d need a reasonable standard. I think that’s the way that it was worded. Just that shift alone overarches everything in the packet. So, I’m not quite sure about that. That being said, I know we don’t have a board of adjustments in this county like other counties have, and so somebody is going to have to decide that, but who is that person? If something’s not clear who do we bring it to? Is it the Planning Directors job to clarify all discrepancies? Who holds the director accountable? And it’s no direct finger pointed at any one person. I’m talking about the philosophy of the job and the way the county would run. So that’s just the first point. Moving down to point F the term for abandonment. The actual cessation of any existing use or non-conforming use. I’m kind of thinking the goal for abandonment is that you want the non-conforming use to be -unintelligible- it’s a little confusing to me why we would add any existing use that’s kind of --I mean its non-conforming use that never got permitted anyway right? Marlowe Scherbel “its defining abandonment” Karen Anderson “It’s defining what abandonment is, I’m just not sure any existing use? Do you really want that? I’m just thinking of the full intent of that. Marlowe Scherbel: “It is the cessation, or ceasing of any use though. If you guys put those two words together.” Karen Anderson “On accessory dwelling unit, I think we could benefit from having discussions about accessory dwelling units being allowed. Maybe even possibly they are 1,000 [square feet] not 800 habitable living space given the situation, but we’re at 800 then the maximum of 1000 square feet of habitable living, habitable living maybe 1,500, 2,500 square feet. I mean there’s just the numbers going down to accessory -uh- acreage. The surface acreage comma net, the surface area within the property line of existing – maybe you could put excluding platted roads and lot setbacks not just excluding roads. That’s a discussion to be had. Continuing down to an addition, construction that expands the building origin.. the building’s original floor plan. Theres the word, quote, building permit rather than a floor plan, but you know, there’s been some discussion about how that impacts footprint. You usually don’t get a floor plan in Lincoln County without a permit. Right? Its not required is that right? Ken Kuluski “that’s correct madam chair” Karen Anderson “okay, so I’m just saying, just that one definition alone, we might have a discussion about building permit, so when were trying to entertain a motion tonight on which ones are the push-through, we can do these now, and they’re great, we’ve done the work, versus some of these things… and I’ve only gone through the first – I mean ive read the whole packet, but as far as starting with an I that we were going to go through all of these like I mean, how do we make a motion? What are the implications of it? I would feel that the direction I would like to take or throw out the to the board is that we possibly go ahead and table this until the February meeting until February and that we, with gentle, comment of bring forward either the top two big controversial issues and then here’s the packet of the go to’s that Marlowe just referred to that are - these are really good changes, these aren’t going to ave a huge impact to the community. We don’t need a huge staff report on all of these. These are just pretty each changes that are 11 necessary that aren’t gonna keep us here for 8 hours of discussion and impact joe and Mary and sue and developer and nuclear and it’s a lot and so I just don’t know how we entertain a motion tonight to accept this entire packet the way it is. Although, granted, I think there’s been an incredible amount of work on this. I just think there’s still a lot of questions. Questions about this – uhm- building – here’s one – quote any structure at having a roof supported by columns or walls. Does that include shed? Does that include a pole barn? Does that… without a wall, is that now a building? I mean, it’s pretty – any- having a roof supported by columns or walls? I’m just kind of concerned about questions, and I’m not a planner I don’t work in the planning office full- time, it’s not my pay grade, but then we get into the campground definition. Cemetery seems ok, central sewer water treatment…. It just seems like we would need a staff report on the bigger ones about why is the change needed, what is the impact for the community that going to help the questions that were opposed by … you know, does it help us accomplish our goals, and is it aligned with.. in… with the regulations, so I’m a little overwhelmed, just to be quite honest. Hunter Jasperson “Madam Chair” Karen Anderson “yes” Hunter Jasperson “My suggestion is that we table it until April, because February is too soon with new Commissioners getting sworn in in January for them to catch up and want to do their [own] changes, its gonna be a whole, whole new ball game. So we table it till April, we have a lot of community outreach so that they can come to our workshops because we don’t really announce them openly as we should so they can come in. give them more input and work with us instead of having it in a very formal setting, it can be more casual, there’s one of me here to cover all of South Lincoln County and four of you to cover all of North Lincoln County, we can do it. Stretch out the – so we don’t stress ourselves out. Karen Anderson “and I don’t think it’s the intent of my discussion anyway I’m not trying to say oh let’s just put it this off. I mean we have to address this issue, and you’re trying to address the issue but… duly noted that its too big of an elephant to chunk through in the nighttime here or daytime in a 1-hour 2-hour 3-hour public hearing. It kind of needs to be downsized enough that we can – it’s manageable for a talking point. Because, granted, the campground issue came up but as soon as some of these other things come up there may be some unintended consequences to just one-word change that we haven’t explored yet and yet the process does have to take place, and it has to go on. So I would, that, those are my comments I’ve talked enough, are there any other board members [with] comments and discussions? And thank you Hunter, too. Member of the Public “can I just say one thing?” Karen Anderson “we;;, right after the board finished, then yeah sure. I don’t know how the rest of your- Chad Jensen “I would actually tend to agree I mean I, you know, were an interesting county in that I hear everybody in Kemmerer, love Kemmerer area, love to go camping out in Kemmerer. The issue is completely different there than here. Its not affordable housing, yeah its completely different, so I completely understand that. [at] the same time I’ve heard the discussion tonight. I have a trailer house sat at home in my shed that’s plugged in. I guess it’s a – I have two residences on my property, I did not realize that. But at the same time, but at the same 12 time, I’m very sympathetic in that exactly as Marlowe said, I mean, I had a lot of people calling me going, I don’t want 10 trailer houses on the lot next to me, so I understand that. So you’ve got to balance the issue of do we, as Star Valley want – I appreciate the comment on what your goals. We don’t want star valley to be one large trailer park from – and I don’t think any of is do. I mean, think about the long-term implications there. But are we there to jump? I don’t think so. Its interesting that this become the.. such a major issue in terms of the whole picture of what we’re trying to accomplish for the county as a whole, which is unfortunate because there’s, there’s, a lot of stuff in here that has pretty big impacts and its not – I don’t think the trailer houses are a small portion of it, but its kind of been blown- and nobody has – lets be very honest, no one has bad intent, I mean lets be honest, were trying to –“ Karen Anderson: “well grappling with growth is hard. Trying to find the overlays and to define where you’re gonna have your high density where you’re gonna have your affordable housing where you’re gonna its these are problems that not just our community are struggling with but if you can barely keep our wheels spinning with the current load you just don’t have time to be designing the plan with the end in mind, and putting those rules and regulations in place that Mr. Call was talking about, you know, with the systematic and responsible change. It’s a big deal. It takes a lot of skill set. And I don’t think I am I am not prepared tonight to sit here and go through each and every one of those that many definitions and I would feel like there might be some unintended consequences that I don’t know about yet, with even just one or two. I didn’t have a chance to reference these [papers handed out at the meeting i.e. emails from Star Valley RV Park] and I’m sure they’re accurate but one time before, we had a draft here, draft here, but it didn’t – there were a couple things changed between that one and this one and then you have to go back and cross reference all 60 changes again and make sure they’re all the same draft that were talking about. I just I just don’t want to pass something through with an unintended consequence. I some inclined to table this. Now going to a time line, it would be, I mean April point taken, new Commissioners on board, their first meetings in January. That’s a tough one to take your first time in office and if you go April point taken by Ken they’d like to be working on this through winter how do we get the cart going forward? And so I’m just throwing that out there and you guys discuss some more now. “ Chad Jensen “ I do like Hunter’s thought, I mean I think I that a great point. New Commissioners, actually, I’m very sympathetic to that. It does seem kind of… the timing… doesn’t seem very well to hurry and pass this this month and then throw it on when new Commissioners are coming in. So that should be kind of like, done in tandem. Do like that. I would actually support, I guess, I’ll guess make the tabling idea, I like it. It gives us more time to work on it, get some more public comment and obviously get to where we want to be. It’s interesting though we’ve gone through all this and not had any comments at all on other segments. Karen Anderson “yeah were there any that rang out? I mean some of you were at the workshop some of us were not at the workshop and it was an hour or two with lunch well designed and planned by Ken. Kudos for that, that communication piece,” Kevin Kilroy “you know the camping one we came a long way from the original one, but I still think there’s a ways to go. And I think it needs to be a multipart definition. I do think there is many parts of that, you know, whether it’s a family reunion whether it’s you know living,-- Karen Anderson: “ I do think maybe there’s a whole table for that, right? 13 Kevin Kilroy: “I think that’s an animal itself. But yet I’m not ready for this one, so were there some other – Karen Anderson “ I want- I’m curious if there were any areas specifically that called out to you as you were reading through these that I mean like I just started to go through alphabetically but I just saw the writing on the wall that this is just some big thing. David Oates: “There is but its not going to get solved now.” Karen Anderson “Which one was kind – not to talk you through it but- David Oates: “Childcare, childcare says one persons gonna have 3-10 kids -- one persons not gonna handle 10 kids. So but anyways its just --- Karen Anderson: “alright so if we were to table it which we are allowed to do then what timeline are you thinking would be an appropriate timeline and of course its with the caveat of maybe it’s best to break a couple out and- and have a staff report with just the one big one, the campers, campground RVs that. David Oates: “which is the easiest way to control this mess? Start at the beginning and just table it and say were going to take the first two pages? And then the next two pages?” Karen Anderson: “Ken how about your suggestions now that you’re hearing us chew this over? Is there something that you think would facilitate…” Ken Kuluski: “I’m gonna have a workshop anyway so whenever we table it it’ll have a workshop the months prior.” Karen Anderson “ and then how would you feel is the most expedient for managing your office and personnel on brining something forward to us, not a big document. Ken Kuluski: “once you guys go through it -” Karen Anderson “you still want to do the whole big elephant” Ken Kuluski “- you can individually send me the stuff, right that’s your, 1, 2, 3, 7 whatever that number is I can complete that list and then create the workshop based on that. Karen Anderson: “can you shunt this for us with that you think are the most important things for the county, or you’re only wanting to do it as a big everything. Ken “in my opinion they build together. So it could go 7-1, 7-2, 7-3, but 7-2 and 7-3 are dependent on 7-1.” Karen “but then you could just handle the campground and then dependent on all the thread, argyle sock, all the threads that go through those four sections that deal with that?” Kevin Kilroy: “7-1 is 15 pages” Ken Kuluski “so you could do that, though you would be better to just – because when you table it right the document stays the – Karen Anderson “I’m going to have you come up here for they can hear and see you I’m so sorry” 14 Ken Kuluski “so is we want to do it that way right, because it was presented as – I’m not allowed to modify a tabled document. I can have workshops right, and I can make notes, and then well get up and well present. Because there’s no decision that can be made on a tabled document. So if you’d like to review – well just say revamp the process right, to where you say ok March we’re gonna go through pages 1-3, June were gonna go through 3-6, August we’re gonna go 6,7 through 9 of whatever that number is. That would be best negotiated with a denial here. Then you guys put that together as a board through emails to me and then I will re break that stuff down for you. Because I cant – there’s not a way – it is one elephant I cant –“ Karen Anderson “but if we go to a denial then that, this goes straight to the current [Board of] County Commission[ers].” Ken “no it doesn’t” Karen “yeah” Ken “no it doesn’t, it stops. And I can bring back –“ Karen “but you can then bring the appeal back in” Ken “I’m not gonna appeal it. I can just start over with page 1” Karen “I think we will just table – I mean I’m in favor of tabling. I think that’s a better route.” Austin Dunlap “the point I think he’s [Ken] trying to make is that tabling it keeps it as it is. And its sounds like from your discussion- Karen “No, no no, no, no.” Austin: “ it needs to change, so if you want to table or if you deny it” Karen: no, no, no, no. Austin: “then you can break it down.” Ken “ And remember we only have two tables right, we have the boards table and the petitioner table, right? So if we table it once we have one more workshop -” Karen “do you want to withdraw it tonight?” Ken “I don’t want to withdraw it I – Karen “you don’t want to withdraw it tonight that’s what I know.” Ken “I have a boss right, and I have direct guidance that I am not allowed to withdraw it anymore because I’ve withdrawn the last-“ Karen “you withdrew one time” Ken “one or two times.” Karen “ it was one time, then it [was] brought forward and then last time it was lets just get this through let just get this pubic noticed so that we can go 30 days because if we –“ 15 Ken “either way I recommend denial. Then you guys can email me how many pages you would like to see. Then we will only have one more table, so well still have to get through 7-1, 2, and three within 2 tables.” Karen “we can” Ken “if that’s what the board thinks we can do then I support the table, but if you want it – I mean it seem to me you would like it broken in much smaller place- pieces. I don’t think we can get that in two tables.” Karen: “So ok, at any rate, thank you Ken, back to board discussion.” David Oates “I recommend denial then.” Karen “I don’t know” Chad “Kens already said he’s not gonna bring it back.” Ken “I’m not going to appeal it, I will bring it back to board discussion” Karen “NO. then it goes to the current Board of County Commissioners.” Ken “it doesn’t go anywhere” Kevin Kilroy “its land use it stays with us.” Ken “its land use, its doesn’t automatically go” Karen “it died and gets brought back on appeal which would be in November” Ken “No, you have to file an appeal, I’m not going to file an appeal on a document that wasn’t approved by the community. That would be-“ David Oates “if we deny it?” Ken “then its done.” Kevin Kilroy “we can modify it” Ken “then I can change it and bring it back one page at a time” Karen “I don’t think that’s how this reads. I just don’t think that’s how this reads.” David Oates “Karen, he says if we deny it he can bring it back one page at time or how ever we want.” - Unintelligible conversation from multiple parties – Karen “well denying and tabling are two big things here right now as far as which Commissioners are gonna see this, the current ones or the new ones.” Ken “table or denial will both go to the new Commissioners.” Karen “I don’t know” Kevin “if we table we can discuss it but not modify it.” 16 Ken “workshop and modify.” Chad “we only get two tables, that’s my concern” David “I don’t want to table it, we don’t have enough tables.” Ken “that’s my concern” - Unintelligible- Karen “so then what happens? It just dies? And then they still have to bring forward chunks-“ Ken “no I can bring one page in April next year” Karen “Correct that’s right” Ken “whatever you want” Karen “you could bring in a chunk and start to think it through.” Ken “as large or as small as you like” Karen “right” Austin “Madam Chair, you gotta remember too the smaller you go you still have more of a process that goes with it. It has to come here. It has to go on a 30 [notice] it has to –“ Karen “its does, but these are big things” Austin “no I know, I’m just saying that if you’re going to do a page at a time you’ll have four or five months per page.” Ken “a page at a time was just a –“ Karen “this is just ridiculous” Austin “the principal is what I’m trying to communicate, if you go that route you have to be aware of the built in time mechanism. There will be 30 day notices, and workshops and 30 day notices.” Karen “and then you get a lot of public comment, and I’m with Hunter, then you’ve got time for the new Commissioners to get grounded. They’re not going to be able to handle all this in December and you know the current ones” David “my comment is is if we deny it and in our denial can we state that we would like to bring it back in March in do 6 pages at a time?” Karen “no it goes to a 30-day file [notice]” Ken “alright, yes you’re more than welcome in your reason for denial to put any feedback you wish okay? Any statement alright?” Karen “but how many of you guys are gonna do that?” Ken “as a matter of procedure I will follow the guidelines to the best of my ability right? Obviously the one page was an exaggeration right?” 17 Karen “But you have a boss who doesn’t want you to table it right now?” Ken “I was asked politely not to withdraw it, to bring it forward and to have it voted on by this board. So a denial shows lack of development or community input or support – whatever term you’d like to put on that final denial statement. That will be the end of it. Then I will bring it back in the future some time, I wont say March because we have other developments, but we will come back and revisit it in the future at a smaller or more appropriate size. However that works at that time will be determined on that time.” Karen “but if you file an appeal, even though you’re saying – right now you’re saying you’re not, what if you change your mind and you do? If you did hypothetically if you file an appeal then this will go to the Commissioners in November, correct?” Ken “it depends on when I filed the appeal, for your example, if I walked in my office tomorrow, filled out the form and signed it then yes, it would probably go in November, because it only has to have a two-week notice. –“ Karen “And it goes straight to them and dies here but its gonna go to the current Commission” David “that’s only if you table it” Karen & Ken “no that’s if he/I appeal it” Karen “he’s saying he’s not going to but he can change his mind and I’m not questioning integrity I’m questioning process here.” Ken “there is no reason as a public servant to bring forward something that is predominantly disliked by the public. That would be, that’s just not the status of the, job. I mean I have a level of competent enforcement, a high level of compliance enforcement in the two years I’ve been here. I have a fairly good record of dealing with people if there’s lack of confidence in it we can revisit it, its not a timed event. Its not a race.” Karen “ok so… thanks. Any other discussion or questions for Ken or Austin?” David “we need a motion” Karen “I make a motion to table file number 604 PZ 25 until….” Ken “I just need the month Madam Chair, because the dates aren’t set, we wont set them until January - ” Karen “March of 2026, 2027, because based on the fact that in the background report explanation from the planning staff it says the Planning and Zoning Commission and the Board of County Commissioners have expressed a desire to clarify chapter 7 of the land use regulations and this is far more than clarifying, this is changing the law in over 65 places. Period. That’s my motion. Its way more than clarification. There needs to be some time to observe this, so that’s my underpinning for the reason why we should table this. So I have a motion, is there a second?” Hunter “seconded.” Karen “we have a motion and a second, is there now any discussion.” 18 Hunter “I would caveat into the reasons is that we didn’t have enough community outreach on these and now that we have gotten these back and gotten feedback we need to get a better system or more feedback before we introduce it for the 30 days.” David “do you want to table it or deny it? Because table it he cant change it, deny it he can.” Karen “he can change it and bring it back later, I mean he can bring changes after its tables. He can still chunk it later, when we have a new Commissioners in office.” Hunter “if we deny it, it will go back to the way it was and they cant look at what were trying to change now.” David “ok but if we table it then you’ve only got two other time frames you can table it. And then you’re done.” Ken “well one more” David “you’ve got to do the whole document, at least half of the document by the next time because you only get one more table” Hunter “were getting 5 months to do community outreach to figure out what else needs work.” Karen interrupts David asks Hunter to repeat himself. Karen, Chad and Kevin whisper to themselves. Hunter “this gives us a frame work to build on, like turning a pole barn into a house.” Chad “you’ll have to be the deciding vote on that” Marlowe “is there a mechanism to help with - ” Karen “just a second” David “question, if we table it now, what happens when we come back and deny it what happens then?” Ken “same as if you denied it tonight.” Karen “Okay, are you ready for a vote? Or do you want more discussion?” Ken “were all still a team, were all a positive team together, we need to be walking the path to the future together.” Karen “I think there’s so much frustration I’m just trying to figure out what the easiest way to do this so all in favor say ‘aye’” Hunter “aye” Karen “aye” David “aye” Kevin “aye” Chad “aye” 19 Karen “hearing none, motion carries unanimously.” Marlowe “can we ask what will happen between now and March or are we just gonna have a meeting in March?” Karen “no let’s ask what will happen between now and March because months pass and things will start all over.” Ken “so we will start with the idea of gathering, so the Commissioners take their time and go through as you already said madam chair, and send me a list of all the hot topics right?’ Karen “and I think that the board really does need to send the issues to Ken, just like really interactive not just here at the meeting. “ Ken “and lets just say 60 days for that right? Plus I’m not saying it takes a gym , I’m saying within 60 days I get those, and I’m sure there will be overlap of topics. When I will schedule at least one, possibly two workshops before the march meeting to discuss those so that we can come up with what my addendum will look like. Then I can add an addendum to this document so it’ll be the additional pages with that extra data because you’re tabling this for me to get more outreach as to what Hunter said. And then I have to present that addendum to the board with in accordance with our board.” Karen “so then does it get publicly noticed again or not and that’s the newspaper?” Ken “yes the Star Valley Independent and Kemmerer Gazette and of course the website.” Karen “thank you moving on” Hunter seconded, motioned passed 5-0. VII. SKETCH PLANS None VIII. OTHER PLANNING MATTERS Karen had questions and concerns about the Planning and Zoning appointed attorney, Austin responded that he was hired as a contracted employee for the Planning and Zoning Commission. Karen posed a question about how the Planning and Zoning Commission could assist the Planning office, in terms of more staff, the pay, technology and training. Many of the board members agreed that the Planning Office is understaffed and that the Planning and Zoning Commission fields a lot of calls. Karen asked if anyone would want the training videos or PowerPoints from Austin on how to make motions and participate in the Planning and Zoning Commission. Discussion ensued about training and possible onboarding for Hunter. 1. Chad provided articles to Ken to be added to the record. 20 IX. ADJOURNEMENT Kevin motioned to adjourn the meeting at 9:30 PM, Hunter seconded. Motion passed 5-0. The minutes from October 21st, 2026, Planning and Zoning Commission meeting were approved on the _____ day of _________________, 2026. _____________________________________ _____________________________________ Chair Dated Director Dated